11 min read

It's About To Be The Stupidest Week* In History**

*month+ // **for covering videogames
It's About To Be The Stupidest Week* In History**

Grand Theft Auto VI comes out this week. It will both swallow up all videogame discourse and, somewhat tragically for the terminally online, kill off the "We Got [X] Before GTA VI" meme (Does this morph to GTA VII as of Nov 20 and should it?)

GTA VI's release is prime brain worms area for mainstream press outlets eager to slurp up the excess froth on the Google Search and ChatGPT queries for GTA VI. Which means we're very likely about to experience the stupidest week(s) in history for coverage of videogames by the mainstream press.

💡
I'm writing this post as a companion piece to an article published in The Guardian today, regarding GTA VI's proposed effects on productivity across the globe, which is really a story about how the media needs to do More. As generative AI insidiously weaves its way into the production of every piece of content you see from LinkedIn posts and major indie videogames to whole journalism websites, pulling the curtain back on the Process of Journalism is a powerful way for audiences to understand what they're seeing online.

Just look at what we've experienced to date. This headline was pushed to my phone in the last 48 hours:

"The unexpected health warning ahead of highly anticipated video game release"

Whatever could it be? This piece, which I will not be linking here, was published at Nine and written by Rachael Gavin. It describes "concern for players' bladders". This concern comes from, as you might expect, a urologist with years of ex—

Wait, sorry, this concern comes from Victorian Plumbing, an online bathroom retailer headquartered in Leyland, UK. Victorian Plumbing, obviously deeply concerned about Gamers' internal plumbing as much as their washrooms. The Nine piece quotes Alex Woods, a representative somehow affiliated with Victorian Plumbing, discussing the potential that delayed toilet breaks will lead to UTIs.

a screenshot of the Victorian Plumbing website showing a host of tabs and sales
The key voice on Grand Theft Auto VI... a bathroom retailer.

Mr Woods must have some qualifications that demonstrate his expertise in the area? Nope, he's the Digital Marketing Manager and his LinkedIn shows he has a Master's degree in Creative Writing. Certainly the type of credentials that I hope to find when dealing with bladder issues.

Presumably no one told Gavin about the invention of the Pause button.

Fascinatingly, this piece takes a turn towards the GTA sicks phenomenon; that marketing-massaged silly-story that, in recent weeks, outlet after outlet has published. The pieces follow familiar patterns, decrying the potential for the game to upend productivity as mass sickies threaten bosses' ability to staff their cafes and worksites and orgs.

In Nine's piece, Gavin quotes Employment Hero's Global Insights Lead, who says – and I have copy-pasted this direct –

“While we can conclusively point to a reason for this significant spike, when you have an event that has mass appeal among this demographic – such as the launch of Grand Theft Auto V1– inferences can be made as to which factors could be driving the increase,”

[Grand Theft Auto V1?] Huh? VEE ONE? FIVE ONE?

I was at the end of my EB tenure ahead of Grand Theft Auto IV's release, and I remember so many kids (certainly below the required age to purchase GTA V) and parents of kids (certainly below the required age to purchase GTA IV) coming in and asking for Grand Theft Auto Eye Vee*, but I wouldn't expect a National Masthead to not understand Roman numerals.

I reached out to Gavin but she did not respond before publication.

CTA Image

If you like this, you will love CONTINUE magazine which is infinitely more thoughtful and premium than my silly little blog.

Buy a print magazine in 2026? Why, don't mind if I do!

This is the tip of the iceberg, as mainstream press clambers to cover a cultural moment that it is fundamentally ill-equipped to handle. Another example? A Sydney Morning Herald business piece on November 12 took the "sickies" story and ran with it too. It's headline:

"‘Gotta prioritise things’: Bosses brace for a wave of GTA6 sickies"

It cites first a "PR consultant" named Eitan Soloducho, who estimates launch day will cost the Australian economy $70,000,000—an assumption based on the notion that "one in 100 of Australia’s roughly 14 million workers pulls a sickie to play the game."

There's simply no data for this, and the journalist does little to confirm these claims. Weirdly, Soloducho does not appear in any other news stories I could find via a quick Google besides another piece from Nine.com.au, maybe where the SMH/Age got the figures (SMH is owned by Nine). Soloducho's claims are based on a sick day costing $500 in output. Or, it seems, they're just made up? Soloducho did not respond to a request for comment either.

Many different claims exist for how many workers take a sickie in Australia each day, with an old AFR report (2012) stating the Bureau of Statistics says 2.6% of Australian workers are absent on a single day due to ill health. If that figure has held at all, then the GTA VI sickies would likely not even register. Indeed, some stories have spoken to this point—that it's not a phenomenon worth discussing. And yet, here we are.

The same SMH sickies story also cites workplace management platform Deputy, as well as uses data from another employment software firm, Employment Hero. In both cases, these companies had sent out press releases with figures the SMH appears to have republished without question. Those press releases are the same ones in which Employment Hero's Global Insights Lead called the game Grand Theft Auto Vee One.

The statistics from Deputy are rather strange, too. Many articles in the mainstream press lifted quotes from this release, which included comments from Chief Technology Officer, Ciaran Hale. Hale claimed "The real trap for businesses is the day-before download spike" but this seems nonsensical. Businesses should be worried about people taking the day before off? That's just decidedly untrue for this release. The SMH hand waves that away but prints the copy-paste quote all the same.

The SMH report is just one of many but it caught my eye because it involved the use of quotes and data from three places that really have no Inside Ball angle on GTA VI. They're employment and staffing platforms looking to get their name out into the world. This... is called "newsjacking" and I would hope that our best journalists don't fall for it.

FWIW, no one in the SMH piece is actually taking a sickie. In fact, people have planned time off with leave. This is interesting–leave is an entitlement and does not contribute to lost productivity. Many other outlets did not speak with sickie-takers (and yeah, sure, there's a reason but we have background and anonymity for these situations) and instead used the same data.

You don't need to do this Sunrise. Who is this for?

Sunrise posted about bosses bracing, too (in a truly embarrassing TV segment where one panellist kept calling it Fast and Furious and also mentioned taking Donkey Kong sickies...), News24 quoted the same employment platform, The West (also owned by Nine) repeated the embarrassing GTA "vee one" copy-paste quote, The Herald Sun went with the "bosses brace" line also, again citing all of the same data and statistics everyone else did (though its article was a lot more detailed).

It's strange that all of these stories take the side of bosses, no? Like there's some imperative to catch out people for calling up sick and playing a game. Freakin narcs.


WANTED

I dropped a short piece about GTA VI sickies on The Guardian today. The Guardian had asked me to look into the sickies phenomenon all the way back in September.

One of the themes that emerged early was that there was a lot of coverage of this phenomenon previously (for GTA V) and there were increasing amounts for GTA VI. Australia's Fair Work Ombudsman had 'grammed something silly about sick days and GTA VI which really tipped coverage in the mainstream over the edge.

In researching the piece, I spoke to a number of videogames academics and writers about the hype around GTA VI and economic activity. I also put a call out, multiple times, to hear from those taking sickies—guaranteeing anonymity.

It seemed obvious there were no solid, robust statistics underpinning economic and productivity predictions, that the staffing and leave data was useful but only to a point and certainly not to the point that headlines were claiming. It just seemed the news had run with more of a vibe; they were reading social media posts and having PR teams newsjack their inboxes and it's GTA! It's news!

Many of the conversations I had with academics did not make the cut for The Guardian—the word count I was given was 800 and I think I promptly went over it. But there were interesting tidbits shared with me that I think would be useful to probe elsewhere.

For instance, Daniel Joseph, a digital sociologist at the University of Manchester raised the idea GTA VI could very well be the last game in this, sort of 'quadruple-A' space and, even suggested that it kind of signifies the ill health of the industry; GTA VI is an exception to the rule, developed at a scale that no other videogame company can really match. He also mentioned how GTA VI sets the media agenda, rather than the other way around and there's not many topics that can do that. That feels true, given the media we've seen.

Jacqueline Burgess at the University of the Sunshine Coast was also very helpful in pulling apart the scale of the GTA VI phenomenon. What I got from our conversation is that the very idea that other people think they're going to miss out because others are taking the day off and racing through the videogame. I felt that. I used to hate when my friend Kevin was further ahead in Kingdom Hearts than me. Prick. (Love ya mate)

Another, George Osborn, author of Power Play: Video Games, Politics and the Battle for Global Influence, presented an interesting idea that, at least in the UK, GTA VI might contribute to economic indicators like consumer price inflation. He told me:

In the UK, top-selling video games, consoles and game subscription services are three of the 760 items used to calculate the Consumer Price Index (CPI), which acts as a measure of inflation. That means that if the costs of games go above their usual level, that can increase the rate of inflation. This happened in July 2019 when – as absurd as this may sound – the remake of Crash Team Racing and the release of Fire Emblem: Three Heroes pushed the average cost of a game above the usual 'summer game drought' average, briefly putting the Bank of England over its then achievable target of 2%.

Grand Theft Auto VI could have a similar impact because the current top-selling version of the game is the premium edition, which costs £89.99 compared to the £69.99 cost of the base game. And though the CPI has adjusted its basket in the past five years to put less emphasis on games in the CPI calculation, there is a chance that lots of sales of GTA VI at a price way higher than the usual Triple A average could unexpectedly shove consumer price inflation up.

Admittedly, I didn't have the time under deadline to really investigate Osborn's claims myself here, but they raise a really interesting downstream effect of a videogame release I just haven't seen discussed at all.

These are interesting conversations worth having—they illuminate ways in which videogames like GTA VI are intertwined with culture and business at a deeper level than "This game is going to cause chaos for employers!" and "Don't forget to go pee-pee, you silly gamers!"


WASTED

Unfortunately, the vast majority of mainstream media outlets are not equipped to deal with a game like Grand Theft Auto VI because the vast majority of mainstream media outlets do not employ journalists assigned to that beat.

You do not need a PhD in media to understand this. Generalist journalists who dip their toes in the videogame world, or are themselves playing a lot of videogames and would consider themselves Gamers, are different to reporters who have cultivated contacts in game studios, attended major and minor community events, spoken with developers and players and insiders and academics; news beats and niches are important for those reasons, no matter what newsrooms try to sell you today.

I Will Not Rest Until The National Broadcaster Hires A Videogames Reporter Full Time
Videogame magazines are really not meant to be here. The internet was meant to kill them off. Plummeting ad revenue was meant to make them obsolete. Vertical video and the attention economy, we were assured, would gobble up the rest of the media. Don't have a TikTok account?–you

Similarly, culture reporters who occasionally cover videogames can do a mighty job, and there are great examples of this, but then there are also accounts that often read as an intrepid astronaut taking their first steps on a bewildering planet that smells of Dorito dust and Mountain Dew. These are the tropes that mainstream media frame coverage on, even if they don't explicitly outline them this way; they wink and nudge at videogames being a kid's thing – surely you wouldn't take a sick day for this! – and then they use headlines like "Levelling up" and "Game on" as if their reporters were recently thawed after being embedded in perfmafrost since 2009.

Keith Stuart, writing at The Guardian in September suggested "...[I]t’s time for the mainstream media to stop treating video games as a novelty that needs explaining". He reasonably asked "is [GTA VI] the most interesting video game since GTA V?" and I think, to that, based on what has been seen so far, the answer is a clear No.

But to mainstream outlets, the answer is a resounding Yes, because they haven't really been following any games since GTA V unless they're Hurting The Children. Maybe Minecraft. Maybe Fortnite. Certainly they have seen and attacked Roblox. But those outlets can see the hype and anticipation that has been generated around Grand Theft Auto VI, typically led by other media outlets or organisations discussing Grand Theft Auto VI. Hollow Knight: Silksong achieved an astounding level of hype and anticipation, too; but I didn't see a single story about taking sickies to play it (Pretty sure I did take a 'sickie' to play it which doesn't mean much as a freelancer).

Stuart writes "Mainstream media is still at the stage where every single games story that does make it to TV or radio has to do the job of explaining and justifying the whole industry."

But he just misses explaining why that's the case. The why comes down to a lack of interest at the executive level, a lack of training at the editorial level and a lack of journalists at the journalist level. (...and this fate is also one science journalism is facing on a longer time scale. That disaster does not seem to be learning anything from this one.)

It is time for the mainstream media to stop treating video games as a novelty, yes, but that starts with hiring people who can show why they aren't.

Such a reversal in longstanding fortunes for the field will not come fast enough to protect against what GTA VI is sure to unleash. So brace yourselves. If GTA VI is going to smash all of those records, I'd bet on it smashing another: Winning the stupidest coverage in videogames history award.

💡
Did I say you should buy CONTINUE magazine? You should. Please visit here and all* your videogame magazine dreams will be fulfilled.

*legally we cannot claim to fulfill all dreams, this is for marketing purposes only, but we will come close. I hope.

*Updated 946am, 16-11: Holy shit, I worked at EB Games during the launch of GTA IV, not GTA V. This has hurt me and my bones have turned to dust, but I updated the post to reflect this.